The $25 viral liquid takes on the $46 powder icon. Only one earns the permanent spot in your bag.
8.4
KADS SCORE
Quick Take
This is a clash of eras: Rare Beauty’s Soft Pinch represents the new school of liquid blush, while NARS Orgasm is the powder that defined blush for a generation. Orgasm’s peachy pink shimmer remains universally flattering and foolproof. But Soft Pinch wins on pigment, wear time, and price, which is why it takes this comparison for most buyers.
What We Like
- Rare Beauty: unmatched pigmentation and 12 hour wear
- Rare Beauty: $25 price undercuts NARS by $21
- Rare Beauty: matte and dewy options
- NARS: foolproof sheer application, hard to overdo
- NARS: iconic peachy pink with golden shimmer suits all skin tones
What We Don’t Like
- Rare Beauty: easy to overapply for beginners
- NARS: $46 for 0.17 oz is expensive
- NARS: powder can look dry on textured skin
- NARS: shorter wear time than the liquid
Product Details
Full Review
Quality
How they compare: Soft Pinch is a weightless liquid in frosted glass with intense milled pigment that melts into skin. Orgasm is a finely milled pressed powder in NARS’s signature rubberized compact, now talc free, with buildable sheer shimmer. The liquid feels more modern and lasts longer; the powder feels more classic and applies more forgivingly. Both are well made prestige products with packaging that justifies its tier.
Value
Price comparison: $25 versus $46, and the cheaper product also lasts longer per application since one dot does a full face. NARS counters with a $33 refill and $36 mini that soften the blow. But on pure value, Rare Beauty wins by a wide margin: better wear, lower price, tiny amount needed.
Who Should Buy It
Buy Soft Pinch if you want bold, long lasting color and the best value. Buy NARS Orgasm if you prefer a foolproof sheer glow and love a classic.
Who Should Skip It
Skip Soft Pinch if liquids intimidate you. Skip Orgasm if you need all day wear or resent paying $46 for powder.
FINAL VERDICT
NARS Orgasm is an icon and remains a beautiful, foolproof blush. But icons can be beaten: Rare Beauty Soft Pinch delivers stronger pigment, longer wear, and a $21 lower price. For most buyers in 2026, the winner is Rare Beauty. Orgasm keeps its crown only for powder purists.
8.4 / 10
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Kads Review may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Leave a comment