Two internet famous cashmere sweaters, one costs half as much, and the cheaper one is the better buy.
8.6
KADS SCORE
Quick Take
This one is not close. Quince sells a 100 percent Grade A Mongolian cashmere crewneck for $50, half the price of Naadam’s $98 Original Cashmere Sweater, and its upgraded pill resistant knit holds up better over time. Recent Naadam owner reviews mention thinning fabric and rising prices, while Quince keeps stacking five star reviews by the tens of thousands. Buy the Quince.
Loves
- $50 undercuts Naadam by $48 for the same 100 percent Mongolian cashmere
- Upgraded pill resistant knit with longer 34 to 36mm fibers
- 365 day free returns, a full year to decide you love it
- More than 34,000 owner reviews with a strong average rating
- Dozens of colors plus extended sizes 1X to 3X
Not For
- Hand wash only, no machine friendly construction
- Light colors like ivory can be slightly sheer
- Online only, so you cannot try before you buy
- Naadam offers more frequent limited edition color drops
The Details
Full Review
Quality
How they compare: build and design. Both sweaters are 100 percent Mongolian cashmere in a 12 gauge knit with a classic crew neckline, ribbed cuffs, and a ribbed hem. Quince specifies Grade A fibers at 15.8 to 16.2 microns with 34 to 36mm staple length, the long fibers being the key to its pill resistance and smooth hand feel. Naadam matches the 12 gauge weight and uses Mongolian origin cashmere, but a string of 2026 owner reviews describe the newer batches as thinner and less luxe than earlier versions. On paper the construction is similar; in practice Quince’s upgraded knit gets the edge for holding its shape and softness longer.
Value
Price comparison. Quince charges $50. Naadam charges $98. That is a $48 gap for two sweaters made from the same grade of Mongolian cashmere, and Quince backs its price with a 365 day return window against Naadam’s standard 30 day policy. Even at sale prices Naadam rarely drops near $50. Unless you are chasing one of Naadam’s limited edition seasonal colors, there is no financial argument for paying double.
You’ll Love It If
Anyone who wants an everyday cashmere crewneck in real Grade A Mongolian cashmere at the lowest price the market offers should buy the Quince.
Skip It If
Shoppers hunting Naadam’s limited edition seasonal color drops, or anyone who wants to try on in a store, should look elsewhere.
FINAL VERDICT
Quince wins this comparison by a clear margin. It costs half as much, its pill resistant knit is engineered to last longer, and it comes with a full year of free returns. Naadam built the affordable cashmere category, but Quince now sells the better sweater for the better price. Buy the Quince.
8.6 / 10
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Kads Review may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Leave a comment